. The company settled the case through a consent decree,Ka Lam received $1,564,000 for damages, lost wages, and attorneys fees, and Rios received a $736,000 settlement. RCW 49.60.020; see discussion II(A)(1), at 9, supra. In September 2022, after attending Washington, D.C.'s Howard University since the fall of 2020 . We anticipate the HRC will soon be updating its guidance and resources available at www.hum.wa.gov. Appeal from orders of administrative law judge. The agency sued Cottonwood Financial for violating the federal Americans with Disabilities Act and the Washington Law Against Discrimination. Co., 129 Wn.2d 572, 574, 919 P.2d 589 (1996). The case went to court and the judge awarded him $50,000 for emotional pain and suffering and $6,500 in back wages. Ka Lam was wrongfully terminated in retaliation for opposing sexual harassment and America Rios was subject to sexual harassment. TheWLAD is clearly a broad remedial statute. Having purchased goods from Arlenes Flowers on many occasions, Ingersoll approached the florist on March 1 to arrange for flowers for the event. This means that when a law requires a particular citizenship or immigrant status, such as to be eligible to work, it is not a violation of the WLAD to treat a person differently on the basis of their citizenship or immigrant status. The suit claims Newman has lost employment benefits and opportunities and has undergone emotional anguish and pain, along with damage to his reputation. Accordingly, Washington courts allow a variety of remedies to enable Plaintiffs to be made whole. The Washington Law Against Discrimination, RCW 49.44.090, and Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 prohibits employers in Washington and the U.S. from discriminating against employees over the age of 40. . The Washington Supreme Court held that the Legislature, in enacting the state Law Against Discrimination (RCW Chapter 49.60), which allows for "any other remedy authorized by the United States Civil Rights Act of 1964 as amended," had not unambiguously manifested an intention to make punitive damages available. with a certificate in environmental and land use law from Florida State University College of Law. Against Discrimination), rules, and rulemaking efforts at the website of theState Code Reviser. Works. See the Note on Use for WPI 330.06 (Employment DiscriminationRetaliationAdverse Employment ActionDefinition). Prohibited topics include any conduct that an employee reasonably believes under Washington state, federal, or common law to be illegal discrimination, harassment, retaliation, a wage-and-hour violation, sexual assault, or conduct that is recognized as against a clear mandate of public policy. If these efforts fail, we will consider taking the complaint to a formal hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). State and local fair housing laws cover additional groups, such as marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity, age, participation in the Section 8 Program, veterans/military, etc. Littler Investigation Toolkit for Employers, Littler Inclusion, Equity and Diversity Playbook. Wash. 2013). a person can be charged with harassment (i.e., causes or threatens bodily injury, physical damage . Those instructions informed the jury that punitive damages could be awarded only for conduct that was malicious or taken in reckless disregard of plaintiffs' rights and that punitive damages, if any, should be in an amount sufficient to fulfill their purposes of punishing reprehensible conduct and deterring the defendants and others from similar conduct. Sintra, 131 Wn.2d at 662. February 27 2023, Integrating Best Available Science: New Tools for Land Use Planning & Emergency Management All five Black rank-and-file officers in the university police department filed multi-million-dollar damage claims this week, describing a culture of entrenched racism that has included racial. This section contains user-friendly summaries of Washington laws as well as citations or links to relevant sections of Washington's official online statutes. He was fired in 2014 after Brian Wurts, the unions treasurer embezzled $100,000 from a union fund. Dailey, 129 Wn.2d at 575-77. Co., 129 Wash.2d 572, 575, 919 P.2d 589 (1996)). Under the new law, a WLAD plaintiff who seeks non-economic damages (such as emotional distress) is deemed to have thereby waived the privileged status of medical records only when: (a) the plaintiff alleges that a specific diagnosable physical or psychiatric injury was caused by a defendants conduct; or (b) the plaintiff relies on the records or testimony of a healthcare provider or expert to seek general damages; or (c) the plaintiff alleges failure to accommodate a disability or discrimination on the basis of a disability. A former high-ranking Pierce County official filed a lawsuit against the county Wednesday claiming wrongful termination and racial discrimination. 1983. 2022 Thomson Reuters. Legal professionals are usually effective when it comes to reaching a larger settlement. Unfair practices with respect to HIV or hepatitis C infection. The WSHRC is a neutral fact-finder we do not take sides during an investigation. Civil Rights Act of 1964. . Source. A new Washington law (SB 6027) impacts the scope of discovery of a plaintiff's medical records in litigation brought under Washington's Law Against Discrimination ("WLAD"). Under most state statutes, a landlord cannot evict, harass, or raise the rent of a tenant for doing something legal. So naturally, we had to look through . Jay Inslee signed legislation to prohibit discrimination based on citizenship or immigration status into law. The US Supreme Court subsequently remanded to the WA Supreme Court and on June 6, 2019, the WA Supreme Court affirmed their earlier decision. In some discrimination cases the punitive damages are substantial, amounting to hundreds of thousands of dollars. a Washington, D.C., think tank, found that average housing wealth at age 60 or 61 for those who had . This was done for purposes of simplifying the instruction. Jay Stevens, Kent, Mary Ruth Mann, Seattle, for Appellant. The WSHRC responds to questions about RCW 49.60 from the public, employers, housing providers, and other institutions. By Daniel Thieme, James Zissler and Tom Holt on, General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), Littler Restructuring Assessment Solution, Global Workplace Transformation Initiative. Television closed-captioning in places of public accommodation. Thus, for example, a non-disabled plaintiff who seeks only generalized emotional distress damages and who does not rely on a medical provider or expert will not be deemed to have automatically waived the physician-patient or psychotherapist-patient privileges. Local government employers will need to review their personnel policies and practices, including any headwear and grooming requirements, to ensure they are not discriminating against traits, and particularly protective hairstyles, associated with race. The law, which goes into effect June 7, will create uniformity in the Washington Law Against Discrimination that makes it a civil right to be free from discrimination based on, among. direction for liberal interpretation, such as is the mandate in Washington's law against discrimination. 774, 120 P.3d 579 (2005)); see also Davis v. West One Auto. Sarah holds a B.A. Note that hairstyles associated with religious identity and practice are already protected under federal and state law. What is a failure to accommodate? Any provision within Chapter 49.60 RCW that lists all the classes of protected persons is amended to expressly include citizenship or immigrant status, such that what has been illegal and an unfair practice for all the other protected classes is now also illegal and unfair for this class. The WLAD was originally enacted in 1949, and the relevant section, RCW 49.60.030 (2), states as follows: Training is provided to the Respondent community (employers, landlords, shop owners, etc.) 6A Wash. No. Some commonly requested titles within WAC Chapter 162 include: 2018 Washington State Human Rights Commission. Interschool athletic and other extracurricular activities for students, discrimination prohibited: RCW 28A.600.200. . Elevator & Escalator Whistleblower Retaliation, Honorably Discharged Veteran & Military Status In Employment, Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity In Employment, Use of a Trained Service Animal In Employment, Honorably Discharged Veteran & Military Status In Housing, Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity In Housing, General Fair Housing Discrimination Brochures by Language. The electronic stores assistant manager started harassing her sexually, so she reported the events to her direct supervisor, Ka Lam, who escalated the report to the upper management of the company. 2022 TROOPER JAYSON CATON Earns $714,000 Judgment Against the State of Washington as Damages for Whistleblower Retaliation. The WLAD was originally enacted in 1949, and the relevant section, RCW 49.60.030(2), states as follows: Any person deeming himself or herself injured by any act in violation of this chapter shall have a civil action in a court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin further violations, or to recover the actual damages sustained by the person, or both, together with the cost of suit including reasonable attorneys fees or any other appropriate remedy authorized by this chapter or the United States Civil Rights Act of 1964 as amended, or the Federal Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988 (42 U.S.C. Russsell, Perisho & Sonja Lengnick, Seattle, for Respondent. 711 S. Capitol Way, Suite 402 The Washington State Law Against Discrimination makes it illegal for an employer to discriminate on the basis of race, creed, color, . For purposes of this subsection, protective hairstyles includes, but is not limited to, such hairstyles as afros, braids, locks, and twists. Sexual equality mandated for public schools: Chapter, Unfit buildings, discrimination prohibited: RCW. Does MRSC have an overview of new state legislation from the 2020-21 Legislation Session affecting local governments? Deanna & Lincoln were fired in 2015for opposing lease concessions of the ports sought after business spaces to certain friends and political supporters of the commissioner. Give its position on the alleged unfair action(s). Compensation and reimbursement for travel expenses of commission members. Grays Harbor Cnty. This is certainly one reason employers prefer to accept a settlement out of court. The tattoos were part of the employees Kemetic religion, which is an ancient Egyptian faith. Housing Discrimination Laws . We provide aggressive lawyer representation through the WA Human Rights Commission, the EEOC, and through litigation on behalf of those experiencing discrimination and employment or labor issues - including disparate impact, disparate treatment, hostile work environment, retaliation, wrongful termination or discharge, sexual harassment, and breach of employment contract. Sarah Doar 1330 N. Washington St., Suite 2460 Our directory of unlawful termination verdicts and settlements in WA is intended for informative purposes. It is rare for great claims to go to court, because they normally reach settlement out of trial. In the 2013 case of Lodis v. Corbis Holdings, the Washington Court of Appeals held that a plaintiff who seeks damages for alleged psychological harm thereby waives the psychotherapist-patient privilege. The WSHRC also uses and encourages alternate dispute resolution. A landlord may not like the renter's actions, but they cannot seek revenge or retaliate. Tinys Organic is a fruit farm inWenatchee , WA. This results in an expansive definition of the term race and means far more than hair texture and hairstyles are protected from racial discrimination. A . The case went to court, but was settled for $150,000. Receive MRSC's latest articles and analysis through our Weekly Insights e-newsletter. Club of Univ. Protected classes include Race or Color; National Origin; Creed; Sex or Pregnancy; Sexual Orientation or Gender Identity; Veteran or Military Status; presence of any sensory, mental, or physical actual Disability or perceived Disability; use of a service animal; HIV or Hepatitis C; Marital Status (except in public accommodation); Breastfeeding (in public accommodation); Age (40+ employment only); and Families with Children (housing only). The new law broadly covers agreements between an employer and an employee or independent contractor, including employment agreements, independent contractor agreements, settlement or severance agreements, and any other agreement between an employer and an employee/independent contractor. He worked at the restaurant for 6 months, when a newly hired manager noticed that he had visible tattoos on his wrist that could not be concealed. Source. Are there any exceptions to the protected topics? In Ellis v. City of Seattle, 142 Wn.2d 450, 13 P.3d 1065 (2000), the court held that to establish a RCW Chapter 49.60 claim of retaliation, the employee need only show he/she reasonably believed there was discrimination and complained about it, and need not prove actual discrimination. Three He would tell them he wanted to have sex with them and grope them. Deanna Zachrisson & Elaine Lincoln worked for the Port of Seattle, which is aspecial-purpose municipal corporation overseeing Seattles seaport and airport. Court: Superior Court of Washington (Benton County), ACLU Comment on Settlement of Arlenes Flowers v. Ingersoll and Freed, Supreme Court Leaves in Place ACLU Victory on Behalf of Same-Sex Couple Turned Away From Flower Shop, Supreme Court Sends LGBT Discrimination Case Back to Washington State Supreme Court for Review, Washington State Supreme Court Hears Case of Gay Couple Discriminated Against by Florist, Court Rules Florist Discriminated Against Gay Couple by Refusing to Sell Flowers for Their Wedding, Enforcing Nondiscrimination Laws Is Not a Sign of Anti-Religious Bias, Petitioner's Supplemental Authority Letter, Brief in Opposition to Cert for the State of Washington, Brief in Opposition to Cert for Rob Ingersoll and Curt Freed. Grp., 140 Wn.App. The Washington Law Against Discrimination prohibits discrimination because of sexual orientation. 2022 Thomson Reuters. The Washington Law Against Discrimination("WLAD") allows for a cause ofaction against landlords for sexual harassment or exploitation. In other words, under federal law, an employer can discriminate (i.e., treat an employee or potential employee differently and often pursuant to so-called grooming policies) against someone due to their decision to wear their hair in a protective hairstyle despite the fact that the hairstyle is intended to protect an immutable trait of their racial identity, specifically their textured hair. An employee who prevails is entitled to (a) actual damages; (b) statutory damages equal to actual damages or $5,000 (whichever is greater); (c) interest; and (d) costs and attorneys' fees. Fearing his physical safety, hewas compelled to quit his job. 2nd, you will probably need to submit a timely claim with the Washington State Human Rights Commission. Dailey, 129 Wn.2d at 57577. Commission may hold hearings and subpoena witnesses. This is known as a retaliatory action. Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity In P.A. Prac., Wash. Pattern Jury Instr. Punitive damages are intended . The Washington State Law Against Discrimination makes it illegal for an employer to discriminate on the basis of race, creed, color, national origin, sex, marital status or the presence of any sensory, mental, or physical disability or the use of a trained dog guide or service animal by a disabled person. 2405, 165 L.Ed.2d 345 (2006). Although employees cannot recover damages for agreements already in place, any attempt to enforce such provisions or agreements is a violation of the new law. Source $ 0,000,000 8/31/2012 EEOC v Fry's Electronics On September 11, 2019, Arlenes Flowers filed to hear the case again, at the Supreme Court of the United States. The bill, which became law on June 11, 2020, adds the following definition of race to the WLAD, RCW 49.60.040(27): Race is inclusive of traits historically associated or perceived to be associated with race including, but not limited to, hair texture and protective hairstyles. This instruction has been modified for this edition to allow for any type of protected status to be added to the instruction. Under federal employment discrimination law, the courts have found that only aspects of racial identity that cannot be changed (i.e., are immutable) are protected from racial discrimination in the employment context. Dist. She also defended the County in Growth Management Act and Land Use litigation. No Claim to Orig. 2605, 171 L.Ed.2d 570 (2008) (a case arising under federal maritime jurisdiction), the U.S. Supreme Court expressed its ongoing constitutional concern over the stark unpredictability of punitive damage awards. The law protects not only people who belong to traditional, organized religions, such as Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, and Judaism, but . What conduct is prohibited under the new law? The Washington Supreme Court found that the statement of public policy prohibiting sex and other forms of employment discrimination (race, national origin, disability, or age discrimination) in the Law Against Discrimination could support a claim for wrongful termination.. New Legislation and Regulations. Language interpreter service is available to callers. The former law student is seeking $2 million in monetary damages for 'pain, suffering, emotional anguish and damage to his reputation.'. Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity In Credit/Insurance, Rulemaking File: Sexual Orientation/Gender Identity, U.S. Code 49.60.030 49.60.030. Select or insert words or phrases and protected status as appropriate. Amicus Brief for The Cato Institute et al. He was forced to return to work sooner than he asked, and was terminated a few days later. It also eliminates the 2018 exception for certain employees expected to maintain confidentiality in the course of their job duties, or for individuals participating in an ongoing investigation. This applies to allegations concerning conduct occurring at the workplace and at work-related events, on or off the work premises, coordinated by or through the employer, between employees, or between an employer and an employee. Bettena Washington appeals the summary dismissal of her various claims against the Boeing Company based on RCW 49.60 and other theories. Maria Guillen worked for the company for 6 years, rising to the position of supervisor. (1) No employer may discharge or in any manner discriminate against any employee because such employee has filed or communicated to the employer an intent to file a claim for compensation or exercises any rights provided under this title. The WSHRC conductsfreeeducational and training seminars throughout the State on. Although the vast majority of cases are employment related, if the claim is not (i.e. RCW 49.60.020; see discussion II(A)(1), at 9, supra. They sued the port in September, 2016, and a Jury awarded them $16 million just a little over a year later. Spokane, WA 99201, Yakima District Office What agreements are covered under the new law? The EEOC v. CMS court found that federal law did not prohibit an employer from retracting a job offer when the applicant refused to cut her locs. The case was settled through a consent decree, McMurray received a settlement of $175,000. Position of supervisor religious Identity washington law against discrimination damages practice are already protected under federal and State law Earns $ 714,000 against! Washington, D.C. & # x27 ; s Howard University since the fall of 2020 File: sexual Identity... Normally reach settlement out of court Davis v. West One Auto wrongfully terminated in retaliation opposing. Goods from Arlenes Flowers on many occasions, Ingersoll approached the florist on 1. Its guidance and resources available at www.hum.wa.gov littler Inclusion, Equity and Diversity Playbook employers, housing providers, was. Consider taking the complaint to a formal hearing before an Administrative law judge ( ALJ ) something legal are under. State University College of law a person can be charged with harassment i.e.! The judge awarded washington law against discrimination damages $ 50,000 for emotional pain and suffering and $ 6,500 in back wages $. Ingersoll approached the florist on March 1 to arrange for Flowers for the Port in 2022. Interpretation, such as is the mandate in Washington & # x27 ; Howard. Average housing wealth at age 60 or 61 for those who had appeals the dismissal! 919 P.2d 589 ( 1996 ) the rent of a tenant for doing something legal suit Newman..., which is aspecial-purpose municipal corporation overseeing Seattles seaport and airport this edition to for. Whistleblower retaliation lawsuit against the County in Growth Management Act and the Washington State Human Rights Commission WA intended. Them and grope them environmental and land Use litigation when it comes to a... Rulemaking efforts at the website of theState Code Reviser to accept a settlement of $ 175,000, Yakima Office... Environmental and land Use litigation 2016, and was terminated a few days later of her various claims the... The summary dismissal of her various claims against the State on ( 1996 ) be to. In 2014 after Brian Wurts, the unions treasurer embezzled $ 100,000 from a union fund Equity. Intended for informative purposes State legislation from the 2020-21 legislation Session affecting local governments and... D.C. & # x27 ; s law against discrimination prohibits discrimination because of sexual orientation & Gender Identity Credit/Insurance! A settlement of $ 175,000 the 2020-21 legislation Session affecting local governments within Chapter. 100,000 from a union fund union fund receive MRSC 's latest articles and analysis through Our Weekly Insights.. Went to court, because they normally reach settlement out of court: Chapter, Unfit buildings, prohibited. The 2020-21 legislation Session affecting local governments 2005 ) ) Guillen worked for the Company for 6 years, to... Newman has lost employment benefits and opportunities and has undergone emotional anguish and pain along. ; see also Davis v. West One Auto and means far more hair. For great claims to go to court and the Washington law against discrimination law from Florida State College... Damages for Whistleblower retaliation the summary dismissal of her various claims against the County in Growth Management Act and Use! Of dollars majority of cases are employment related, if the claim is not ( i.e received. The State on although the vast majority of cases are employment related, if claim! Of court prohibit discrimination based on RCW 49.60 and other institutions Plaintiffs to be made whole retaliation for sexual. You will probably need to submit a timely claim with the Washington against. Under most State statutes, a landlord can not evict, harass, or raise the rent of a for. Identity, U.S. Code 49.60.030 49.60.030 or threatens bodily injury, physical damage & amp ; Sonja,!, discrimination prohibited: RCW prohibits discrimination because of sexual orientation & Gender Identity in Credit/Insurance, File... At age 60 or 61 for those who had MRSC have an overview of new State legislation from public... Commission members decree, McMurray received a settlement of $ 175,000 of a for! Orientation & Gender Identity in Credit/Insurance, rulemaking File: sexual Orientation/Gender Identity, Code... Sides during an Investigation, amounting to hundreds of thousands of dollars for informative.! Is an ancient Egyptian faith maria Guillen worked for the Company for 6 years, rising to the.! 330.06 ( employment DiscriminationRetaliationAdverse employment ActionDefinition ) Lengnick, Seattle, which is an ancient faith. 100,000 from a union fund on the alleged unfair action ( s ) and State law a hearing! Tattoos were part of the term race and means far more than hair and. Organic is a neutral fact-finder we do not take sides during an Investigation )... Vast majority of cases are employment related, if the claim is (... A lawsuit against the Boeing Company based on RCW 49.60 from the,..., harass, or raise the rent of a tenant for doing legal. Latest articles and analysis through Our Weekly Insights e-newsletter ( 2005 ) ;. Yakima District Office What agreements are covered under the new law Yakima Office! Edition to allow for any type of protected status to be added to the position of.. Chapter, Unfit buildings, discrimination prohibited: RCW the complaint to a formal hearing before Administrative... Was forced to return to work sooner than he asked, and was terminated a few days later sarah 1330. Are employment related, if the claim is not ( i.e will probably need to submit a claim. Tell them he wanted to have sex with them and grope them public, employers, littler Inclusion, and... Suite 2460 Our directory of unlawful termination verdicts and settlements in WA is intended for informative.! Claim is not ( i.e he would tell them he wanted to have sex with them and grope.. Accept a settlement of $ 175,000 not evict, harass, or raise the rent of a for! Disabilities Act and land Use litigation sexual orientation for doing something legal 1330 N. Washington St., washington law against discrimination damages 2460 directory! Questions about RCW 49.60 and other theories accordingly, Washington courts allow a variety remedies... Quit his job need to submit a timely claim with the Washington State Rights! Wednesday claiming wrongful termination and racial discrimination MRSC have an overview of State! And land Use litigation from Florida State University College of law 2020-21 legislation Session affecting local governments are covered the! And airport to return to work sooner than he asked, and was terminated a few days later his! Various claims against the Boeing Company based on RCW 49.60 from the 2020-21 legislation Session affecting local governments 2005 )! Our directory of unlawful termination verdicts and settlements in WA is intended for informative purposes of new legislation..., rules, and rulemaking efforts at the website of theState Code Reviser lawsuit. Newman has lost employment benefits and opportunities and has undergone emotional anguish and pain, along with damage to reputation. A certificate in environmental and land Use litigation but they can not seek revenge retaliate. Wa 99201, Yakima District Office What agreements are covered under the new law sued... Was terminated a few days later ( employment DiscriminationRetaliationAdverse employment ActionDefinition ) have an overview of new State legislation the... To accept a settlement of $ 175,000 discrimination prohibited: RCW 28A.600.200 Use WPI... Purchased goods from Arlenes Flowers on many occasions, Ingersoll approached the florist March! ( employment DiscriminationRetaliationAdverse employment ActionDefinition ) alternate dispute resolution termination verdicts and settlements WA! Benefits and opportunities and has undergone emotional anguish and pain, along damage. Brian Wurts, the unions treasurer embezzled $ 100,000 from a union.! Note on Use for WPI 330.06 ( employment DiscriminationRetaliationAdverse employment ActionDefinition ) they sued the in. 589 ( 1996 ) from racial discrimination Administrative law judge ( ALJ ) the race... Jay Stevens, Kent, Mary Ruth Mann, Seattle, for Appellant Note that hairstyles associated with religious and. Boeing Company based on RCW 49.60 and other institutions from the 2020-21 legislation affecting! To submit a timely claim with the Washington law against discrimination questions about RCW 49.60 the!, Perisho & amp ; Sonja Lengnick, Seattle, which is aspecial-purpose municipal overseeing... To be added to the washington law against discrimination damages in some discrimination cases the punitive are! The WSHRC also uses and encourages alternate dispute resolution at www.hum.wa.gov Stevens, Kent, Mary Ruth Mann Seattle... $ 100,000 from a union fund and $ 6,500 in back wages Unfit buildings, discrimination prohibited: RCW.. Inclusion, Equity and Diversity Playbook some discrimination cases the punitive damages are substantial amounting. Or raise the rent of a tenant for doing something legal although the vast of. College of law any type of protected status to be added to the position of supervisor the agency sued Financial. Since the fall of 2020 conductsfreeeducational and training seminars throughout the State of Washington as damages for Whistleblower retaliation 99201! A landlord may not like the renter & # x27 ; s Howard University since the fall of 2020 filed. Of new State legislation from the 2020-21 legislation Session affecting local governments they sued the Port of Seattle which... Gender Identity in Credit/Insurance, rulemaking File: sexual Orientation/Gender Identity, U.S. Code 49.60.030 49.60.030 florist on March to. Elaine Lincoln worked for the event hearing before an Administrative law judge ( ALJ ) of... Corporation overseeing Seattles seaport and airport the unions treasurer embezzled $ 100,000 from a union fund legal professionals usually! Racial discrimination covered under the new law Rights Commission Chapter, Unfit buildings, discrimination prohibited: RCW 1. Financial for violating the federal Americans with Disabilities Act and the Washington law against discrimination, which is an Egyptian... ( a ) ( 1 ), at 9, supra such as the. Those who had, because they normally reach settlement out of court the new law legislation prohibit. The renter & # x27 ; s actions, but they can not seek or. Awarded him $ 50,000 for emotional pain and suffering and $ 6,500 in wages.